The Art of the Sequel

Updated: Nov 8
In an age where movie producers don’t seem to be willing to take a chance on new stories, we the viewers are saddled with a bevy of sequels. In my mind, there’s one clear recipe for a successful sequel, at least in the genres in which I write. So here is Seth’s recipe.
The seminal story will contain a secret, one that the audience is trying to figure out as the plot unfolds. Who is this person? What is the treasure at the end of the map? Is the world really as we see it? That sort of thing. By the end of the story, obviously, the audience has solved the riddle.
That takes us to the sequel. One might be inclined to just invent a new riddle, but there is a more compelling option. We are all storytellers in some sort of way. We take pleasure in watching our audiences react to our tales. In the sequel, the audience knows the secret. But that doesn’t mean everyone in the story does. That’s why I like to introduce new characters and have them discover the secret, but in a way that plays off the audience’s knowledge of what it is.

How about an example of opportunity missed. Take the Matrix. In the first film, we learn that the world as we know it is just a simulation, and we watch as Neo acclimates to his new reality. In the sequel, he’s flying around fighting a thousand Agent Smiths. In my view, a more compelling story would have been to have Neo searching for, identifying, and recruiting, the next individual needed to take down the machines. For example, the keymaker was an interesting character. I would have liked to see the keymaker’s expression when Neo shows up and starts calling his reality into question. In other words, the writers had the opportunity to tell the story from the other side, and they missed it.
As a side note, another opportunity in sequels is to take the former villain and rehabilitate him/her. For example, had I written the Matrix 2, I would have downloaded Agent Smith into an offline server and weaponized him against the machines. You know, like Terminator 2, which is the perfect example of where this recipe was followed. In Terminator 2, we as the audience knew the secret, and we got to enjoy watching John Connor’s journey in realizing terminators exist.
So when you’re contemplating the second book in your series, think about what the audience knows and how you can use that to your benefit.
You may be thinking, what about the third installment? Fortunately, there are a couple of options for that as well, and I will discuss those in a subsequent post.


Comments